Why We Need A Real Facebook Subscribe Button For Web Sites

This week, Facebook gave us the Subscribe Button For Web Sites. Unfortunately, the button doesn’t let anyone actually subscribe to web sites, much less the Facebook pages associated with web sites. Here’s what Subscribe does and doesn’t do and how things should change.

Subscribe: Facebook’s Version Of Follow

Back in September, Facebook introduced the concept of Subscribe, along with a new Subscribe Button. It allowed anyone on Facebook to allow others to “subscribe” to their personal profiles.

Personally, the button dramatically changed how I shared on Facebook. I share plenty through my personal profiles on Google+ and on Twitter. But sharing on Facebook meant I had to decide who was my “friend” and let them in to my Facebook profile.

That, along concerns I had with Facebook over privacy, caused me to shift to using a Facebook page back at the end of 2009.

With the launch of the Subscribe button, I no longer had to decide who should be friended. Instead, it allows me to be “followed” by others in the same model that as Google+ and Twitter both allow. All I had to do (as anyone can do) was to allow Subscriptions as part of my account.

Consider this example for Andrew Bosworth, director of engineering at Facebook:

On his page, I get a sad-sounding message that “You and Andrew aren’t friends,” but that’s followed by a note that I can subscribe to him to see anything he wants to share with the world. All I need to do is click the Subscribe button that the arrow in the screenshot points to.

How Subscribe Updates Are Delivered

When you subscribe to someone, unlike with following on Google+ and Twitter, you won’t see everything they post.

Instead, by default, you’ll see “Most Updates,” with Facebook’s EdgeRank algorithm algorithm deciding exactly which of “most” updates you should see in your news feed.

This can be changed by selecting the Subscribe button again and choosing a different option (as shown on the right), though I imagine most people don’t do this.

Updates themselves appear in two places. Most people, I imagine, get updates from subscriptions the old fashioned way. The updates just flow into your news feed, in the same way you get updates from friends or pages you’ve liked.

The Subscription Tab

The second option, which I bet few people use, is using the Subscriptions link, which appears on the left-side of your timeline, marked “A” below:

By default, the Subscriptions tab appears in the “List” area of your sidebar, but you can click to pin it to your Favorites area.

The tab brings up your Subscriptions page, where you can see the latest posts from everyone you’re subscribed to. You can refine this to certain types of updates using the “Updates to show” button marked “B.”

The Subscriptions area marked “C” shows you everyone you’re subscribed to (those who aren’t also friends; by default, you’re already subscribed to friends ).

The “People To Subscribe To” area marked “D” is a really nice way to find good suggestions of those you should follow (and it leads to a full page of personalized suggestions, which is also great).

You Can Subscribe To People But Only Like Pages?

Until now, the Subscribe button only existed within Facebook itself, on personal profile pages. This week’s announcement was about how the subscribe button can now be embedded outside Facebook, on web sites.

Get it? That’s why it’s called the Subscribe Button For Web Sites. You can make one using this generator from Facebook. Here’s an example of the Subscribe button on this web site, for my personal page:

But want to subscribe to our Marketing Land page on Facebook? You can’t.

You can’t subscribe to any Facebook Pages, which means there’s no subscribe button for them, whether those are buttons on Facebook itself or for their web sites. Instead, those pages can only use the Like Box/button for Facebook Pages.

How Like Is Different From Subscribe

It’s pretty crazy that Facebook pages — which are often linked to companies that have web sites — can’t be subscribed to. Examples of this weirdness can be drawn from Facebook’s own photo gallery of publications using these buttons. Consider:

Yes, AllThingsD has a subscribe button on its site, but the button isn’t for people to subscribe to AllThingsD on Facebook. It only lets them subscribe to the Facebook account of Walt Mossberg, co-executive editor of AllThingsD.

Here’s another example:

Yes, TechCrunch has Facebook’s Subscribe Button For Web Sites on it. But pushing that button doesn’t subscribe you to the TechCrunch web site nor TechCrunch on Facebook. It only subscribes them to TechCrunch editor Erick Schonfeld’s account on Facebook.

If you want to follow either of those publications on Facebook, or our own, your only option is to use a Like button.

Unfortunately, liking a Facebook Page doesn’t mean that people will see “Most Updates” from it, as is the case with Subscribe. Instead, only a small percentage (perhaps less than 10%) of all those fans a publication has enticed to “Like” their pages will see any post.

Can Publications & Web Sites Have A Real Subscribe Button, Please?

It really shouldn’t be this way. If someone wants to follow a publication or web site on Facebook, they shouldn’t have to hope that they’re not going to miss content they may want to see, because Facebook decided something wasn’t important enough to show.

Similarly, publications that have helped Facebook grow into the platform it has become by convincing their own readers to follow them there shouldn’t find themselves second-class citizens or worse, be required to pimp their writers and employees as “Subscribe” options in place of the publication itself.

Don’t get me wrong. I love that Subscribe exists and allows for writers to be followed. For individuals and public figures, using Subscribe with a personal profile may make a lot more sense than having a Facebook page. I’ve certainly been finding that, and Facebook has more advice on making the decision here.

But publications need a Subscribe option just as much, if not more so. After all, in what strange world is it where you can’t subscribe to a publication?

I’m hoping to hear back from Facebook more on this issue, including any plans to perhaps bring a Subscribe button out for Facebook Pages. Let’s hope so.

In the meantime, see this past article on our sister site Search Engine Land with tips at the end on how to make posts from your Facebook page more visible.

Related Articles

Related Topics: Channel: Social Media Marketing | Facebook: Pages | Features & Analysis | Social Media Marketing | Top News


About The Author: is Founding Editor of Marketing Land. He’s a widely cited authority on search marketing and internet marketing issues, who has covered the space since 1996. Danny also serves as Chief Content Officer for Third Door Media, which publishes Search Engine Land and produces the SMX: Search Marketing Expo conference series. He has a personal blog called Daggle (and keeps his disclosures page there). He can be found on Facebook, Google + and microblogs on Twitter as @dannysullivan.

Connect with the author via: Email | Twitter | Google+ | LinkedIn

Marketing Day:

Get the top marketing stories daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • http://nicole-simon.eu nicolesimon

    I initially thought as well that this was a subscribe button to the page and thought this would be a RSS killer. Of course, if you had thought about it a minute longer it becomes clear why this cannot be for the website without further setup (like what are the updates of this website which should go into such an subscribe). But of course we as website owners would have dealt with it in order to increase integration and I still believe that Feeds can be killed through facebook and alike.

    Now don’t get me wrong: I hate that RSS (and Atom) readers have not evolved so that fb can come in and take over. But in light of no advancement on feeds it is the logical next step.

    It does bring up new questions though for what I share on my facebook profile and brings up again the point of missing publishing options. You as the writer of this article might share this on your personal profile and become a public persona through this – but that means subscribe to you should have a different meaning than be one of your friends. Otherwise your family and friends will be annoyed by your business stuff.

    All of this would not be such a deal if Edgerank would not be in the mix. If I want to read your stuff, I will not necessarily interact with it – meaning that when I subscribe to you or like the page for your website, it is likely that I will exactly not what I ordered.

    *sigh* we will see where that goes.

  • http://www.LiveSide.net Kip Kniskern – LiveSide.net

    For websites, what would be the benefit (read: difference) of subscribing vs. liking?  Wouldn’t both provide the same service?  I can see the benefit of being able to subscribe to Mossberg, etc., from his All Things D page, that provides new functionality not previously available.  Instead of introducing a whole new button, why not allow websites to set their rate of inclusion on “likers’” walls: “Show all updates on wall posts”.  I don’t see the reason for adding another button that mimics the Like button, and see a lot of confusion possibilities if websites add the (proposed) subscribe button while keeping their current Like button.

  • Anonymous

    Kip, when you Like a page, you’re going to see by some estimates only 5 to 10% of the posts from that page.

    In contrast, when you Subscribe to a profile, you’re going to see as Facebook puts it, “Most Updates” by default.

    That’s the reason why you want to have a Subscribe button. But I think you get that — you just question why the Like button simply can’t work as the Subscribe button does, without us needing yet another button.

    Agreed, that would be great. Maybe Like for pages will change into Subscribe. That would be especially helpful because we have two different Likes going on — the ability to Like (kind of subscribe) to a Facebook page and to Like (kind of share) a page with others. The second Like is, of course, already confusing with the Facebook Share button. Now my head hurts.

  • Anonymous
  • http://www.thewholesaleforums.co.uk Lace Llanora

    Okay I think I get it. Subscribe button is primarily for people/individuals aka CEOs, writers, etc. who have profile pages instead of a fan page – is that right? If that’s the case it totally makes sense as it works similar to Twitter’s follow button.

    But I agree with @KipKniskern:disqus that for FB pages, there’s really no need to introduce another button. Perhaps FB can just let fans decide how much of a page’s update they’ll get on the news feed.

  • Anonymous

    All that we really need is liking a page to be honored by Facebook. If I like a page, I want to see their posts. If it turns out that the posts do not interest me after all, I can just unlike the page.

    How hard would that be to deliver?!? Oh, that’s right… It would lower Ad revenue.

    Because, if people who liked pages actually got to see and comment on the content from those pages, their friends might see their comments in the ticker. And then those friends might be interested and might click through and might like the page. And what would that be? Oh yes, that would be SOCIAL Media. what a great concept!

Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Marketing Land on Twitter @marketingland Like Marketing Land on Facebook Follow Marketing Land on Google+ Subscribe to Our Feed! Join our LinkedIn Group Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Marketing News!

Marketing Day is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!